Monday, July 26, 2010

An Ally of Necessity

The much publicized leaking of several thousand classified documents relating to the war in Afghanistan may have provided the war’s American critics an opportunity to press their objections. It does not, however, make the case against military and political cooperation between the governments of the United States and Pakistan, made necessary by the challenge of global terrorism.

Under elected leaders, Pakistan is working with the U.S. to build trust between our militaries and intelligence agencies. In recent months, Pakistan has undertaken a massive military operation in the region bordering Afghanistan, denying space to Taliban extremists who had hoped to create a ministate with the backing of al Qaeda. Pakistan-Afghanistan relations have been enhanced to an unprecedented degree. And exchanges of intelligence between Pakistan and the U.S. have foiled several terrorist plots around the globe. The WikiLeaks controversy and the ensuing speculation about Pakistan’s role in the global effort against the terrorists should not disrupt the ongoing efforts of the U.S. and Pakistan to contain and destroy the forces of extremism and fanaticism that threaten the entire world.

Pakistan is crucial for helping Afghanistan attain stability while pursuing the defeat of al Qaeda led terrorist ideologues. For that reason the White House, the Pentagon and the State Department have denounced the leaking of unattributed and unprocessed information implicating Pakistan in supporting or tolerating the Taliban. House Armed Services Committee Chairman Ike Skelton, a Democrat, warned Monday against judging Pakistan’s role in the Afghan war by “outdated reports,” adding that Pakistan had “significantly stepped up its fight against the Taliban.” Most Americans and many Pakistanis agree on the need for improvements in Pakistan’s efforts, but that is not the same as suspecting lack of cooperation.

The tragedy that has unfolded in South Asia is the product of a long series of policy miscalculations spanning fully 30 years. The U.S., in its zeal to defeat the Soviet Union—a noble goal indeed—selected Afghanistan as a venue. Pakistan became caught up in an ideological battle between communism and a politicized version of our Islamic faith. The most violent and most radical elements of the Mujahedeen resistance were empowered to fight the surrogate war against the Russians. Concerns—such as former Pakistani Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto’s warning in 1989 while visiting the U.S. that the world had created a Frankenstein monster in Afghanistan that would come back to haunt us—were generally ignored.

Alliances and relationships forged among supporters of the Afghan jihad 30 years ago have not been easy to dismantle within Pakistan. But they have been dismantled. After 9/11, Pakistan made a deliberate and courageous decision to confront the terrorists as the civilized world’s first line of defense. Since the return of democracy in 2008, Pakistan has paid a terrible price for its commitment to fight terrorism. More Pakistanis have been killed by terrorism in the last two years than the number of civilians who died in New York’s Twin Towers. Over the past nine years more Pakistani than NATO troops have lost their lives fighting the Taliban. Two thousand Pakistani police have been killed; our mosques and hotels have been savagely attacked; scores of billion dollars of foreign investment were frozen; and tens of billions of dollars of funding for education and health have been diverted to the battlefield against the extremists.

We cannot undo the past, but we can certainly alter the course of the future. The democratically elected government of President Asif Ali Zardari and Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani has followed a clearly laid out strategy of fighting and marginalizing terrorists, even when that decision was less than popular with a public still cynical because of what it believed was the political manipulation of the past. The course laid out by Pakistan’s democratic leaders has been executed brilliantly by Pakistan’s military and intelligence services.

The documents circulated by WikiLeaks do not even remotely reflect the current realities on the ground. For example, a retired Pakistani general is named as the master planner of the Afghan Taliban’s strategy. But this is a man who hasn’t held any position within Pakistani intelligence or the military for more than 20 years. For its part, Pakistan’s current leadership will not be distracted by something like these leaks. We have paid an unprecedented price in blood and treasure over the last two years. We will not succumb to the terrorists.

As we speak, the military of Pakistan is engaged in a bloody battle, taking enormous casualties, in the mountains of South Waziristan to purge the tribal areas of terrorist sanctuaries. Our intelligence forces are gathering information across the country and targeting terrorist cells in North Waziristan to thwart their designs for destabilizing our government and terrorizing our people.

This is Pakistan’s war as much as it is a battle for civilization. Pakistan’s very existence and traditional way of life are at stake. We fight alongside our friends from all over the world to protect freedom. The U.S could not have a more committed ally in this defining battle of the third millennium than the people, the government and the military of Pakistan.

Written by Ambassador Husain Haqqani.

Tuesday, July 20, 2010

The Begum Chronicles

ChaiChutneyPolitics is proud to be present "The Diary of Noreen Begum." A woman of formidable fashion, she is married to Major General Assad Akhter, and recounts her daily life as a member of Lahore's elite.

-----------------------------------------------------

July 2010

Ufff! Paris mein itni garmi nahin thi!

Yesterday morning, Assad and I landed in Lahore after two months abroad in Europe. Two glorious months!

You just cannot match Europe for the wining and dining, and the things to DO. I cried more coming back to Pakistan than I did at my rukhsati! (Though back then I was weeping for different reasons) I was such a mess at the airport that Assad insisted on buying out the first class cabin on the plane for me. We landed and Saleem met us at the airport and brought us back to our home, Gulshan House.

I hardly recognized the neighborhood. They must be re-doing the streets again. I haven't left the house, I'm still much too distraught to do anything but mope and look at our vacation pictures. I swear, I'm so much more beautiful in Europe, the lighting does wonders for my skin. Here? The government thinks we don't NEED lights for ten hours a day!


Assad suggested I take up writing to pass the time. Who has the time to write when she could be shopping instead? Long shirts are back In style. Last season short shirts were in and so naturally I threw out all my long ones. Now I must have Bunto Kazmi make her fashions for me again.

Chalo, enough writing for now. The new episode of "Mere Saas Ki Bi Ek Saas thi...Aur Uski Bhi Ek Saas Thi" is on soon!

Monday, July 19, 2010

Democracy In A Box

Democracy: (noun) Pakistan's unattainable state of social, political and economic utopia

Many in Pakistan want a stable democracy with strong institutions, and I support that goal wholeheartedly. It is a noble endeavor, and the only way to move Pakistan forward. The problem is that many people who demand democracy seem to think it can happen overnight. They want it instantly. And that is where the problem lies.

Democracy cannot appear at the wave of a Presidential wand, nor can the National Assembly (talented bunch though they are!) conjure up a self-sustaining system. In order for a true democracy to take root, we must stay true to its principles and give it a real chance to develop. Most importantly, we must understand that democracies evolve.

Let's compare ancient Greece, the birthplace of democracy, and the United States, the nation that leads the free world today. Greece, divided into smaller city-states, gave rise to the early democracy of Athens. Ancient Athenian men gathered in town meetings and voted directly on the laws people would follow. Women were not permitted to participate. Modern-day United States has a population exceeding 300 million; clearly, people cannot vote directly on legislation. Americans vote for Representatives, Senators, even for the members of the Electoral College, who in turn vote for the President. The direct democracy of Athens hardly exists in today's America.

Like Greece, the only people allowed to vote in the early days of US history were men - specifically, white, landowning, Protestant men. The Declaration of Independence reads "We the People," but who the "people" were exactly would be debated and modified for years. In time, owning property was dropped as a requirement. Voting was extended to all white males. Then, to males, to women, and in the 1960s, guaranteed for all American citizens. When people demand equality and the system delivers, that is truly a beautiful accomplishment. American democracy is not perfect. Challenges exist, but the government allows for complaints to be heard, for the Constitution to be modified if warranted. Democracy is allowed to breathe.

Pakistan's multiple attempts at democracy show a determined will of its people. Interrupted by military dictatorships, destroyed by martial law, and forgotten as the nation was mired in wars, democracy has a real chance now. The importance of this moment cannot be stressed enough. Imagine holding a rare gem in your hands. You cannot become distracted and carelessly lose it. You absolutely cannot run so fast to keep it safe that you drop it. No, you must hold it carefully, set it in a proper frame, and one day show it to the world.

That is how we must treat the political situation today. Understanding that we should push steadily in a progressive direction is the only way we can become s progressive nation. Allowing the Pakistani people to actively participate in an increasingly-solid democratic system is the key to our future. The people have never had a chance. A democratically-elected government has never finished a term. We must change that. We must set the precedent, we must allow democracy to flourish. We must prove cynics and naysayers wrong, and we must allow a democracy to take root.

It will not be perfect. But the beauty is, a democratic country must always be in the pursuit of perfection, and therefore, it is never complete nor perfect.

Wednesday, July 14, 2010

Varying Degrees of Reality

To an avid spectator of Pakistani politics, manufactured hysteria is a sad reality. To the same spectator, there is nothing surprising about the media's seeming obsession with the educational histories of elected officials. The accusing, spiteful and politically-motivated mud-slinging is just another instance where cheap points are scored at the expense of the people. The fact is, people vote leaders in to provide a better quality of life and represent their voices and concerns. Yet, somehow our leaders consistently get caught up In self-righteous quicksand. These fake crises overtake our beloved leaders and we are the poorer for it. I say "fake crisis" because there is no shortage of very real and terrifying issues for Pakistanis. Those issues are overshadowed and those voices are muted. That is the real crisis.

Do we vote for or against people based on the schools they attended or what they have made of their education? Of course not. It would be much more scandalous if leaders had won their positions of power through fraud or cheating. But to say someone does not deserve to represent people because s/he didn't attend a prestigious school is absurd. Having a degree from a well-known educational institution implies one comes from a family or background that was able to accommodate the financial burdens. Most Pakistanis are poor; the notion of having so much money to spare -enough to fund a comfortable lifestyle and education - is a dream. The countless stories of young children forced to work to help their parents are a testament to the generational poverty that exists in our country. Pakistan's middle class would face difficulties, as well.  Are these people barred from running for office? Are these people not fit to participate in society? If voters feel the MPs have cheated, they will vote them out. Let the awam respond to the fake degrees and make a statement through the ballot box. Let there be a referendum, a statement by the people on the issue of fake degrees. That is, after all, how a democracy should work.

This "crisis" is feudalism in another suit. For years, the elite aristocracy ruled the land, making rules and regulations in it's favor and depriving the poor of social mobility. The fake degree crisis is another attempt to maintain that status quo. That our leaders lied about their degrees is of course wrong, but the idea that one NEEDS a degree to serve Pakistan is the bigger injustice.

A quick Google search for "Pakistan fake degrees" shows a myriad of international newspapers talking about the Pakistan MP degree scandal. At a time when Pakistan is struggling to improve her economy, fighting increasingly inhumane terrorists and strengthen democratic institutions, these headlines harm our image.

We need support to tackle our issues. Instead of reporting tirelessly on an inconsequential issue, these writers could have been changing people's perceptions about Pakistan. We are a proud and hard-working people. In the midst of enacting much-needed social reforms, building infrastructure and dealing with a dangerous water crisis, we must also contend with political stunts and international scrutiny.

It is inexcusable to deceive your colleagues and your constituents about your educational background. But it is absolutely wrong to assert one should come from a wealthy enough background to have such an impressive degree. A good degree does not guarantee good judgement. Any Pakistani fairly voted into offices qualified for that office.

Now. Let's talk about a real issue.

New Blog

Hello!

I am continuing my blogging from www.sanavision.wordpress.com. I heard so much about blogger that I thought I'd join.

Welcome to chai, chutney and politics!

- Sana